Sunday, October 25, 2026

REVIEW: Charlotte's Web (book) by E.B. White, illustrations by Garth Williams

Charlotte's Web is a children's book. I bought my copy new.

This review is, I guess, spoilery? It's hard to say. 

Review:

Eight-year-old Fern is horrified when she learns that her father plans to cull a piglet who's the runt of his litter. Her father reluctantly lets her bottle feed the pig, which she names Wilbur, and he thrives, but eventually he grows big enough that Fern's father insists he has to be sold. Luckily, Fern's Uncle Homer is willing to buy him, so Fern can continue to visit him daily. Wilbur's new home is much more boring than living with Fern was, and he struggles to find a friend until he meets Charlotte, a spider.  

This was a reread that I was prepared to have reduce me to tears, but to my surprise it wasn't nearly as much of a "crying book" as I recalled. There was lots of warning about Charlotte's eventual fate, if you knew to pay attention to it. It was sad to know she was alone at the end, but Charlotte herself was never shown to be afraid or regretful. She'd accomplished what she'd wanted to accomplish.

I couldn't help but laugh at the number of people who conveniently accepted that it was Wilbur who was special because that's what the words in Charlotte's webs said, even though the actual miracle everyone kept witnessing was a spider who could write. It might've even been frustrating, if Charlotte had wanted recognition for her work, but for her, the most important thing was that her friend Wilbur was safe.

I had forgotten that Fern could hear and understand what the animals were saying (to the point that her parents, particularly her mother, were worried about her). While I understand that it was part of showing that she was growing up, it made me a little sad to read about her going to the barn less and less to spend time with Henry.

All in all, this was an enjoyable reread. I liked the way White accepted all the animals as they were and didn't try to sanitize their natural behaviors to make them "nicer." Wilbur genuinely enjoyed laying around in mud and manure, and Wilbur's initial impression of Charlotte was that she was bloodthirsty, due to her diet of live flies, but that was just part of how she lived.

Extras:

Black-and-white illustrations throughout. Also, my copy of this book included a nice foreword by Kate DiCamillo. 

No comments:

Post a Comment